If 40c aint big enough due to rocks n roots etc, then your mtb is a better choice anyway.Karvalo wrote:What point? I can't be bothered to watch quarter of an hour of gcn waffle to find one opinion.warthog101 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 8:49 amHe makes that point in the 2nd video.Karvalo wrote:Rocks and roots. Places where it's silly not to be riding an mtbwarthog101 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 6:05 amI am wondering what terrain is being ridden for 700x40 to be too small?
Sand, mud, snow?
Bike loaded for touring?
Still, if you aren't after speed, and riding in soft stuff, loaded bike packing, then fair enough I guess
I don't ride big 650b for soft stuff, I use it for hard, bumpy and jagged stuff.
Does 650B still make sense when you can fit 700x45 tyres?
Moderator: Moderator Team
-
- Posts: 913
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:05 am
True - but what that point misses is how perversely fun it is to wrestle a gravel bike around terrain that everyone around you is tackling with 140mm+ of suspension. It doesn't sound fun, I didn't even think it would be fun until I got dragged out to try it.... but damn it is fun.warthog101 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 11:48 amIf 40c aint big enough due to rocks n roots etc, then your mtb is a better choice anyway.Karvalo wrote:What point? I can't be bothered to watch quarter of an hour of gcn waffle to find one opinion.warthog101 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 8:49 amHe makes that point in the 2nd video.Karvalo wrote: Rocks and roots. Places where it's silly not to be riding an mtb
Still, if you aren't after speed, and riding in soft stuff, loaded bike packing, then fair enough I guess
I don't ride big 650b for soft stuff, I use it for hard, bumpy and jagged stuff.
Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓ Broad Selection ✓ Worldwide Delivery ✓
www.starbike.com
-
- Posts: 83
- Joined: Sat Jun 02, 2012 2:42 am
I suppose that's true if your ride has nothing but MTB type of terrain. But the whole point of a gravel bike is to handle mixed terrain. A gravel bike with 45-50mm tires is still going to be way faster on the road than any serious MTB, especially if you choose a tire that rolls well. If you have a ride with a wide mix of terrain, from pavement to light MTB terrain where a wider tire helps, then a gravel bike with wide tires makes a lot of sense.warthog101 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 11:48 amIf 40c aint big enough due to rocks n roots etc, then your mtb is a better choice anyway.
-
- Posts: 913
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:05 am
I am fairly new to gravel.tritiltheend wrote:I suppose that's true if your ride has nothing but MTB type of terrain. But the whole point of a gravel bike is to handle mixed terrain. A gravel bike with 45-50mm tires is still going to be way faster on the road than any serious MTB, especially if you choose a tire that rolls well. If you have a ride with a wide mix of terrain, from pavement to light MTB terrain where a wider tire helps, then a gravel bike with wide tires makes a lot of sense.warthog101 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 11:48 amIf 40c aint big enough due to rocks n roots etc, then your mtb is a better choice anyway.
However wide tyres like that aren't what I am seeing with respect to gravel bikes where speed matters.
The first video I linked shows an ex protour rider who now gravel races.
Using under 40c from what he said, unless snow, sand or slop, where you need more surface area to avoid ploughing.
The recent gravel race I did was gravel road.
No wide tyres seen at all.
If you are just cruising around, loaded or riding soft stuff or really rough stuff, then yeah go large.
Going to be slower on gravel tracks/roads though.
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 11:23 am
I run 700x50 and 650x2.1(54) but both tyres have differnt purposes. 700c is for general use and gravel up to grade 3/4 while the 650b is a MTB tyre for grade 5 gravel and anything requiring MTB grip.
So 650b is dead for a large group of people who have gravel bikes but those that push the limits of their gravel bike, 650b still has a purpose assuming you use MTB tyres with it.
So 650b is dead for a large group of people who have gravel bikes but those that push the limits of their gravel bike, 650b still has a purpose assuming you use MTB tyres with it.
-
- Posts: 111
- Joined: Fri Oct 26, 2007 1:26 am
I really like drop bars. Not that it's impossible for drop bars to go on a mtb, but I don't a bicycle with that setup.warthog101 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 11:48 amIf 40c aint big enough due to rocks n roots etc, then your mtb is a better choice anyway.Karvalo wrote:What point? I can't be bothered to watch quarter of an hour of gcn waffle to find one opinion.warthog101 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 8:49 amHe makes that point in the 2nd video.Karvalo wrote: Rocks and roots. Places where it's silly not to be riding an mtb
Still, if you aren't after speed, and riding in soft stuff, loaded bike packing, then fair enough I guess
I don't ride big 650b for soft stuff, I use it for hard, bumpy and jagged stuff.
Makes perfect sense....but 700x50 is pretty fat for doing a multi purpose ride. I use a 42mm Ultradynamico tire which measures 40mm on an Enve G23 rim on my Factor LS. I think the height/diameter of the 700x50 (larger) vs. 650x2.1 (smaller) would be extreme. You can get away with a 38mm or 42mm wide tire on 700 and still be okay on mixed road surface.BuffHamster wrote: ↑Tue Nov 30, 2021 9:12 amI run 700x50 and 650x2.1(54) but both tyres have differnt purposes. 700c is for general use and gravel up to grade 3/4 while the 650b is a MTB tyre for grade 5 gravel and anything requiring MTB grip.
So 650b is dead for a large group of people who have gravel bikes but those that push the limits of their gravel bike, 650b still has a purpose assuming you use MTB tyres with it.
I think if I were to do a 90/10 gravel to pavement ride...I'd go with the 650b with a 2"+ tire. Most of my rides are 80/20 to 60/40 pavement to gravel and the 38mm is good (80/20) and 42mm good for 60/40.
- Factor Ostro VAM Disc
- Factor LS Disc
- Specialized Aethos Disc
- Sturdy Ti Allroad Disc
- Guru Praemio R Disc
- Factor LS Disc
- Specialized Aethos Disc
- Sturdy Ti Allroad Disc
- Guru Praemio R Disc
I ride quite a bit of singletrack on my gravel so I've recently picked up a set of 650b wheels specifically to run MTB tyres - Race Kings.
I've also got a set of 700mm wheels which are great for actual gravel but on more technical stuff (particularly tight turns) when running tyres larger than 42mm they steer like a tank.
On a 29er MTB suspension allows you to 'run-over' obstacles (within reason) that you can't navigate around. Frames with long reach and short stems also keep the steering much more responsive.
I suspect bike geometry plays a considerable part in peoples experiences of both, bikes like BMC URS mimic MTB geometry more closely so are probably better suited to using 700mm wheels on singletrack.
Ultimately it depends on what terrain you ride and how much fun you have when doing it. Though if I was racing gravel I'd be using my 700mm wheels for sure.
I've also got a set of 700mm wheels which are great for actual gravel but on more technical stuff (particularly tight turns) when running tyres larger than 42mm they steer like a tank.
On a 29er MTB suspension allows you to 'run-over' obstacles (within reason) that you can't navigate around. Frames with long reach and short stems also keep the steering much more responsive.
I suspect bike geometry plays a considerable part in peoples experiences of both, bikes like BMC URS mimic MTB geometry more closely so are probably better suited to using 700mm wheels on singletrack.
Ultimately it depends on what terrain you ride and how much fun you have when doing it. Though if I was racing gravel I'd be using my 700mm wheels for sure.
Just a word of warning on Race kings - had my first 'wipe out' using them this morning - front tyre slide right out from under me and I ended up hugging a bush.
Was only on less than 1" of mud on a very gradual turn.
Was aware that they're not a wet / mud specific MTB tyre but thought I'd be able to get away with it as I would only be using them in pretty tame MTB territory.
Think I'll be sticking with my Terrenos for the mud.
Was only on less than 1" of mud on a very gradual turn.
Was aware that they're not a wet / mud specific MTB tyre but thought I'd be able to get away with it as I would only be using them in pretty tame MTB territory.
Think I'll be sticking with my Terrenos for the mud.
Noted. It was on a trail I've ridden pretty regularly in fairly similar conditions with Vittoria Terreno and Pirelli Cinturato M without issue.
Tempted to give Vittoria Barzo's a go - anyone got experience with these?
I've been riding 2.1" Barzo front and Mezcal rear and been very impressed. Great compound for wet rock/root grip as well as tread pattern. Different class to the Race King.
I got my GT Grade carbon pro with some Zipp stuff and WTB Nano's (700 X 40c). I just put some 700 X 33s on it: Gravelking AC's, the two together under 600 grams.
This week all parts arrive to tune it for heavy gravelride: DT Swiss GRC 1400 in 650B. I already have some Teravail Rutlands ready in 650 X 47c.
As far as I can assume and "calculate" those will be the smallest setup by a tad, giving me a bit of extra gearing for heavy climbing (packed or not).
And for some extra headroom (it's a Shimano gravel with GRX)... Garbaruk derailleur cage, jockey wheels and 11-50 cassette.
The WTB Nano's roll very nice on pavement: I took them out on a socalled easy ride (I wanted to put in a little more effort), and ended up dike racing on my smallest cog.
One of the Gravelking AC's was a pain in the %$* to fit. Needed a serious booster pump for it. The other one was ok. They roll nice, and go fast on light gravel. A few roots and some MTB climbs went well, except one with a sandy sloping top. So I can't wait to go out with the 47's. That's 1.85... and that was the size of my 26" Ritchey Z-maxes I rode on my Cannondale M800 on serious MTB routes (Ardennes Belgium, around Bouillon, Houffalize,...).
So to those claiming the future is 50.... then 55.... boy oh boy... you sound like those guys with the first fullies and fat green Michelins. We (former brother in law and me) raced them on a local technical loop, and they tailed us hard... LOL. And their feet got wet when stuck in the middle of a mudpool too while we dredged through it. All I saw after that, was bigger and heavier rubber. Why? For comfort? It seems so if I read the comments here. Grow a badass butt, get on a real hardtail and get over it. I'm wandering when the pendulum will swing back... because I honestly believe the centerpoint is way behind us now, despite hookless tubeless cornering-less wheel setups. They already tried something like 100 inch wheels... somewhere in the 19th century I guess. Just my two cents.
This week all parts arrive to tune it for heavy gravelride: DT Swiss GRC 1400 in 650B. I already have some Teravail Rutlands ready in 650 X 47c.
As far as I can assume and "calculate" those will be the smallest setup by a tad, giving me a bit of extra gearing for heavy climbing (packed or not).
And for some extra headroom (it's a Shimano gravel with GRX)... Garbaruk derailleur cage, jockey wheels and 11-50 cassette.
The WTB Nano's roll very nice on pavement: I took them out on a socalled easy ride (I wanted to put in a little more effort), and ended up dike racing on my smallest cog.
One of the Gravelking AC's was a pain in the %$* to fit. Needed a serious booster pump for it. The other one was ok. They roll nice, and go fast on light gravel. A few roots and some MTB climbs went well, except one with a sandy sloping top. So I can't wait to go out with the 47's. That's 1.85... and that was the size of my 26" Ritchey Z-maxes I rode on my Cannondale M800 on serious MTB routes (Ardennes Belgium, around Bouillon, Houffalize,...).
So to those claiming the future is 50.... then 55.... boy oh boy... you sound like those guys with the first fullies and fat green Michelins. We (former brother in law and me) raced them on a local technical loop, and they tailed us hard... LOL. And their feet got wet when stuck in the middle of a mudpool too while we dredged through it. All I saw after that, was bigger and heavier rubber. Why? For comfort? It seems so if I read the comments here. Grow a badass butt, get on a real hardtail and get over it. I'm wandering when the pendulum will swing back... because I honestly believe the centerpoint is way behind us now, despite hookless tubeless cornering-less wheel setups. They already tried something like 100 inch wheels... somewhere in the 19th century I guess. Just my two cents.
Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓ Broad Selection ✓ Worldwide Delivery ✓
www.starbike.com
What do you guys think of Gerard’s perspective on 650b vs 700c, about halfway through this Exploro Ultra introduction?
https://blog.3t.bike/2022/04/18895/intr ... oro-ultra/
https://blog.3t.bike/2022/04/18895/intr ... oro-ultra/