Moderator: Moderator Team
I realized that today while installing a new chain, the derailleur was a bit loose, it appears like it comes from the spring's attachement. Bolts are all tightened, the loose is only apparent when the chain is removed and the derailleur has no tension in it.
Anybody else noticed this?
Sorry that I don't have any info for you right off the bat, but could you perhaps offer some more detail on this play that you feel? I might just be thick headed, but I can't quite visualize which direction the play is in from your description.
When you mention the spring, are you talking the parallelogram spring, or the spring the tensions the lower cage with jockey wheels?
Is the play for/aft, side to side/ etc?
If it's easier, could you perhaps draw some arrows on an photo to illustrate it?
If it is in the parallelogram spring, does it only exist when shifted to the smallest cog position?
Out of curiosity, with the chain off, does simply shifting up to the next cog position alleviate the play?
If so, when you feel this play in the spring attachment point, does there appear to be tension on the spring or is it slack?
If it is small cog specific, I am guessing that either your parallelogram spring is too long due to stretch/manufacturing error, or your dropout/hanger/hub geometry may be out of spec just enough to place the derailleur inboard enough, so that you are operating at the very edge of its effective range of motion, which leads to the spring being detensioned when in the small cog position. Obviously, it has been shifting OK, so unless you are a total perfectionist there is probably no reason to do anything about it, but it would be interesting to compare your derailleur to a brand new one to check the spring's free length, or put your derailleur on a different bike/wheel combo to see if existing limit screw settings place the pulley farther outboard.
You could also try building up the attachment points of the spring or something like that to increase its tension...M950 XTR had a cam adjustment for parallelogram spring tension so you could choose between more light action or positive shifting, but I don't think newer versions feature that. You also used to be able to get aftermarket higher tension springs, but I haven't seen those in a while either.
It is all good when on the smallest cog and small ring. When feeling the play, the spring seems totally slack, no tension.
Maybe this is why I sometimes hear a weird grinding noise when going from the 34T to to the 36T...?
It seems really strange that "It is all good when on the smallest cog..." which is when the spring should have the least tension.
The weird grinding noise from the 34-36 could also be a result of insufficient "B" pivot tension which is causing the top pulley to foul on the largest cog when shifting. Chain length can play a role here as well.
Agree with TheKaiser, the grinding going into the biggest gear is likely not enough B-tension, try turning it in only one half to one full turn if it's only happening once in a while.
TheKaiser wrote:unless you are running a low normal (Rapid-rise) derailleur, which I don't think they ever made in a Shadow+ version. Is my assumption that you are running high-normal (parallelogram spring pulls der to smallest cog) correct?
There is no 10 speed rapid rise (more is the pity), so any shadow plus (10 speed only - until 11 comes along from Shimano) has to be high normal, yes.
Budget 26" HT build viewtopic.php?f=10&t=110956
- Similar Topics
- Last post
- 0 Replies
- 225 Views
Last post by muffinman
Sat Feb 24, 2018 1:15 am
- 15 Replies
- 1646 Views
Last post by wheelsONfire
Fri Aug 11, 2017 2:56 pm
- 3 Replies
- 282 Views
Last post by simoncx
Wed Apr 25, 2018 8:47 pm
- 1 Replies
- 325 Views
Last post by TobinHatesYou
Fri Mar 09, 2018 7:11 am
- 12 Replies
- 1389 Views
Last post by sungod
Sat May 26, 2018 5:14 pm