I am going to be getting myself a new Wilier Cento 1SR in the coming months and I am weighing up groupsets. I've read a lot of reviews and SRAM always gets a good rating which seams to be weighted to it's lower price point.
I would like to hear your opinions on which is the best mechanical groupset REGARDLESS OF PRICE.
1. Shimano Dura Ace 9000
2. SRAM Red 22 (Not hydraulic brakes)
3. Campagnolo Super Record
You might struggle to get anyone to reply who has had experience with all 3 of these groupsets.
I have mecanical 11sp SR on my Bottecchia SP9. For comparisons sake I also have a Colango C50 with 11sp Record and a Master X light with Athena 11sp. I also rode a Giant TCR Ad1 with Ultegra 6700 for a few years.
Campagnolo hoods are easily the best contoured for a smaller hands or if you are like me - a medium sized hand which is battered / weakened - Campy hoods are narrow and well rounded in the right places compared to Shimano hoods which I found too thick and squared off for a hand that does not want to grip a large circumfrence.
Also the thumbshifters on Campagnolo are a deal breaker for me - again, my hands are weak and I do not get on well with having to tap across the brake lever as per Shimano shifting.
Of my 3 Campagnolo gruppos, SR is def. a good deal lighter weight than the others and feels like it shifts slightly better than Record but this may be due to slightly better cable routing on the bike fitted with SR.
My way of summizing a groupset may be different to your way or that of others........ I want comfort over and above anything else and Camapgnolo does it for me in truck loads.
If you are getting a Cento Uno SR in either Black or Black/Red colours then SR will look perfectly matched to these framesets..........
- Posts: 8609
- Joined: Wed Oct 31, 2007 10:32 pm
- Location: Los Feliz, Los Angeles, California
THAT is up to YOU to decide.
And whatever you decide will be great. Have confidence in your own decision and go ride your bike.
Campag is the best developed of the 3, as it's the oldest 11s gruppo. Da is awesome but has a few issues with its rubbish cables and cassette clusters, SRAM doesn't last like the other two do and the std brakes are rubbish. But overall there is nothing much between em..
Sram is my favourite choice for tuning and weight reasons and fits my small hands better than Shimano.
Campag is the one to have on any Wilier tho, mate.....honestly....when I see a Wilier with anything BUT campag, a little part of me dies inside and I feel slightly ill. It shifts great, kicks the shit outta everything else for pure classical style and the cranks are an unheralded gold standard (of standard/ non aftermarket stuff). My G/F would be single if she'd have put anything other than Campag on her Cento Uno Wilier (Anniversary)....even Chorus is a better choice for the Italian steeds than the best of the others (and bear in mind, I ride, and am loyal to SRAM!!)
Edit: 2015: darn near won the best South Island series (got second in age
-group)..woo hoo Racy Theremery is back!!
- Sram fits my hands better (medium hand size)
- Changing the shift cables on SRAM RED is a nightmare! Cable is very hard to bend round and fit through the STI groove. It can take anything between 1min and a few hours to change depending on how lucky you are
- Shimano shifts better but deteriorates faster. Cables are known to break after 2000-3000km.
- Shimano cables are easy to change
- SRAM red cables once installed last a very long time before you notice any issues with shifting
- Very light shift actuation on Shimano so shifting is butter smooth. SRAM has a harder, longer and more firm click feeling. I like both to be honest.
- SRAM is lighter
There is shimano 9001 which I think cures the above issues. I would go with 9001.
It all comes down to comfort and which one you enjoy more. All of the top gruppos (and arguably Ultegra 6800, Force 22 and Record) are going to perform more or less the same. Which hoods fit your hands best? Which shift mechanism do you like the best? Aesthetics? Warranty? Cassette/crank options?
I'm a SRAM guy. I love the shape of their hoods. I love double tap. I love the positive feedback in the rear mech. I love the yaw FD. I love the price/performance afforded by Force. I've ridden Campy Super Record, Red and Dura Ace 9000. They are all amazing but, to me, not worth the price premium over Force/Ultegra.
And cost is always an issue somewhere in there. That's why I don't have any Campy experience.
But I have one bike with DA7800 and one with RED 2013 (Yaw derailleur but Force cranks). While I prefer the idea of the single lever shift system of SRAM, and it does seem to work reliably and adequately, I tell people that if a Shimano user switches to SRAM, the first thing they will say to themselves is "man, these rear shifts are really loud, slow, and clunky!" There is not that much difference in the front. The Yaw requires more careful setup, but the "trim" positions of Shimano are convenient and easy too.
But I am happy with my SRAM, so it is always a series of trade-offs.
Shimano chains and cassettes work better (quieter, more positive shifts) with either setup, even the SRAM. But SRAM is lighter, less $$, and I like the single lever idea rather than a brake lever that swivels.
- Similar Topics
- Last post
- 25 Replies
- 3396 Views
Last post by AZR3
Sat Aug 19, 2017 9:20 pm
- 5 Replies
- 1131 Views
Last post by FIJIGabe
Thu Dec 28, 2017 8:24 pm
- 29 Replies
- 2545 Views
Last post by TonyM
Wed Nov 01, 2017 5:29 am
- 57 Replies
- 4965 Views
Last post by KaiLingMan64
Thu Feb 01, 2018 2:37 pm
- 6 Replies
- 628 Views
Last post by jih
Wed May 09, 2018 5:45 pm