12 speed chain on 1x11
Moderator: Moderator Team
My bike has GRX 1x11 and it's just a tad noisy while using the bigger gears in the back. I'm due for a new chain and wondering if it's worth trying a thinner Campagnalo 12 speed chain for reduced noise, or if I should stick to a Shimano 11 speed chain. Does anyone have experience trying this setup?
Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓ Broad Selection ✓ Worldwide Delivery ✓
www.starbike.com
I read that a Shimano 12s chain works well on 11s
Yes, you can use it with 12-speed pulleys from Ultegra/XT on GRX RD:
for RD-RX817/RD-RX812 (1x11, 11-40, 11-42) you need:
12-speed 11T top pulley from Ultegra RD-R8150
12-speed 11T bottom pulley from Ultegra RD-R8150
for RD-RX815/RD-RX810 (2x11, 1x11, 11-34) you need:
12-speed 11T top pulley from Ultegra RD-R8150 (link - ali: not available yet)
12-speed 13T bottom pulley from XT RD-M8100 (link - ali: €11/$12)
for RD-RX817/RD-RX812 (1x11, 11-40, 11-42) you need:
12-speed 11T top pulley from Ultegra RD-R8150
12-speed 11T bottom pulley from Ultegra RD-R8150
for RD-RX815/RD-RX810 (2x11, 1x11, 11-34) you need:
12-speed 11T top pulley from Ultegra RD-R8150 (link - ali: not available yet)
12-speed 13T bottom pulley from XT RD-M8100 (link - ali: €11/$12)
'
- robbosmans
- Moderator
- Posts: 2790
- Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2018 12:40 pm
- Location: Central Belgium
- Contact:
You can’t use shimano 12s chains on normal narrow wide chainrings you need specific hyperglide 12s chainrings for that, sram and campy should work
Of couse you can and it will work better and it's less noisy as 11 speed. It works (very well) on cranks with 2 blades and also the non Shimano ones; Rotor Qrings for example. There are a lot of posts on this in the road sectionrobbosmans wrote: ↑Fri Dec 31, 2021 8:28 pmYou can’t use shimano 12s chains on normal narrow wide chainrings you need specific hyperglide 12s chainrings for that, sram and campy should work
Last edited by tomtom on Sun Jan 02, 2022 2:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Canyon Aeroad CFR
Canyon Grail CF
Canyon Grail CF
2x11 shimano chain rings are compatible with 12s chain,
but that doesn't mean that 1x11 shimano chain rings are compatible with 12s chain
1x11 chainrings are wider and have specific tooth shape that makes them less compatible with 12-speed hyperglide+ DCE+ specific chains
(12-speed shimano chain spec = DCE+ hyperglide+; 12-speed chimano cassette spec = hyperglide+; 1x12 shimano chainring spec = DCE+)
some 1x11/1x12 narrow-wide non DCE+ specific (non DYNAMIC CHAIN ENGAGEMENT+ specific) chainrings:
works with 12-speed shimano chain with kmc quick link, but doesn't work with shimano 12-speed quick link
but that doesn't mean that 1x11 shimano chain rings are compatible with 12s chain
1x11 chainrings are wider and have specific tooth shape that makes them less compatible with 12-speed hyperglide+ DCE+ specific chains
(12-speed shimano chain spec = DCE+ hyperglide+; 12-speed chimano cassette spec = hyperglide+; 1x12 shimano chainring spec = DCE+)
some 1x11/1x12 narrow-wide non DCE+ specific (non DYNAMIC CHAIN ENGAGEMENT+ specific) chainrings:
works with 12-speed shimano chain with kmc quick link, but doesn't work with shimano 12-speed quick link
'
Ok thanks.....did not know that. I stand corrected ! Quite complex....is GRX 1x compatible with a Shimano 12 chain?ooo wrote: ↑Sun Jan 02, 2022 1:25 pm2x11 shimano chain rings are compatible with 12s chain,
but that doesn't mean that 1x11 shimano chain rings are compatible with 12s chain
1x11 chainrings are wider and have specific tooth shape that makes them less compatible with 12-speed hyperglide+ DCE+ specific chains
(12-speed shimano chain spec = DCE+ hyperglide+; 12-speed chimano cassette spec = hyperglide+; 1x12 shimano chainring spec = DCE+)
some 1x11/1x12 narrow-wide non DCE+ specific (non DYNAMIC CHAIN ENGAGEMENT+ specific) chainrings:
works with 12-speed shimano chain with kmc quick link, but doesn't work with shimano 12-speed quick link
Canyon Aeroad CFR
Canyon Grail CF
Canyon Grail CF
- robbosmans
- Moderator
- Posts: 2790
- Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2018 12:40 pm
- Location: Central Belgium
- Contact:
You misunderstood, we’re talking about 1x narrow wide chainringstomtom wrote: Of couse you can and it will work better and it's less noisy as 11 speed. It works (very well) on cranks with 2 blades and also the non Shimano ones; Rotor Qrings for example. There are a lot of posts on this in the road section
Yes, new pulleys recommended, new chainring required:
GRX rear derailleur ⇒ 12s pulleys ⇒ see post #3
GRX crankset ⇒ 12s DCE+ chainring ⇒ https://www.garbaruk.com/grx-round.html
'
I've found KMC chains work better than any other for 1x systems because they have specific chamfering on all four corners of the outer plates. It genuinely helps avoid noise and chain suck at extreme chain angles. It's really good stuff.
I use KMC x11 on my 1x11 setup (XT m8000) and KMCx10 on my gf's' 1x10 setup (shimano 10 speed road flat bar shifters, 9 speed Altus MTB rear derailleur - long story but Shimano 10 speed road pull ratio works perfectly with 9sp MTB rear derailleurs). I tried an x11 chain on her 1x10 and it worked fine (though not obviously any better than x10).
Anyway, I wouldn't look anywhere other than KMC for 1x setups. Never tried an x12 chain but IF your narrow wide chainring is compatible it might work fine on 1x11.
Edit: There's lots of KMC fakes around. Buy from a reputable store.
I use KMC x11 on my 1x11 setup (XT m8000) and KMCx10 on my gf's' 1x10 setup (shimano 10 speed road flat bar shifters, 9 speed Altus MTB rear derailleur - long story but Shimano 10 speed road pull ratio works perfectly with 9sp MTB rear derailleurs). I tried an x11 chain on her 1x10 and it worked fine (though not obviously any better than x10).
Anyway, I wouldn't look anywhere other than KMC for 1x setups. Never tried an x12 chain but IF your narrow wide chainring is compatible it might work fine on 1x11.
Edit: There's lots of KMC fakes around. Buy from a reputable store.
My Campagnalo 12spd chain came in today, and I can confirm it fits the GRX chainring and derailleur pulleys without any interference. However, the shifting performance is noticeably poorer than using a Shimano 11spd chain. More derailleur tension is needed for the thinner chain to catch the shift ramps, especially on the smaller cogs. This results in unwanted contact in the larger cogs, and is noiser overall than before.
Back to the Shimano chain for now. For the next test, I'll look into the KMC X11 chains mentioned by robertbb since it seems like those should work pretty well with 1x drivetrains.
Back to the Shimano chain for now. For the next test, I'll look into the KMC X11 chains mentioned by robertbb since it seems like those should work pretty well with 1x drivetrains.
I had skipping with a few gears on my red cassette.. FD worked alright. The skipping was under power mostly it was annoying so I went back to 11sp chain
2024 BMC TeamMachine R
2018 BMC TImeMachine Road
2002 Moots Compact-SL
2019 Parlee Z0XD - "classified"
2023 Pivot E-Vault
2018 BMC TImeMachine Road
2002 Moots Compact-SL
2019 Parlee Z0XD - "classified"
2023 Pivot E-Vault
-
- Posts: 783
- Joined: Wed Dec 07, 2011 1:26 am
- Location: California's country side
I had installed the wolf tooth chainring onto GRX crank (very easy). It has a lot chains it can go with below (although not Shimano 12 speed)
"Use Drop-Stop B for all 9, 10, and 11spd chains or 12spd SRAM Eagle, SRAM Flattop, Campagnolo, KMC, Connex or Wippermann chains"
It also hold the chain better,when cleaning sometimes I get a small piece of paper towel onto the GRX chainring it wants to skip and derail and the wolf tooth is not affected.
Also if you want to, get a smaller chain ring then you don't have to use the largest cog in the back which has very high friction and noise.
I am running KMC 11 speed chain. I didn't think running 12 speed chain I am afraid the thinner chain will break because it sees many 17% climbs.
"Use Drop-Stop B for all 9, 10, and 11spd chains or 12spd SRAM Eagle, SRAM Flattop, Campagnolo, KMC, Connex or Wippermann chains"
It also hold the chain better,when cleaning sometimes I get a small piece of paper towel onto the GRX chainring it wants to skip and derail and the wolf tooth is not affected.
Also if you want to, get a smaller chain ring then you don't have to use the largest cog in the back which has very high friction and noise.
I am running KMC 11 speed chain. I didn't think running 12 speed chain I am afraid the thinner chain will break because it sees many 17% climbs.
Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓ Broad Selection ✓ Worldwide Delivery ✓
www.starbike.com