Merlin Malt G1X thoughts?

Especially for light weight issues concerning cyclocross / touring bikes & parts.

Moderator: Moderator Team

Post Reply
alpinestar
Posts: 158
Joined: Wed Dec 04, 2013 8:37 am
Location: Lyngby, Denmark
Contact:

by alpinestar

Just saw this for the first time today: Image
Looks like a really good deal with a solid setup, apex groupset, zipp components and mavic wheels.
https://www.merlincycles.com/merlin-mal ... 50729.html
One letdown is the finish on the welds! The geometry is a bit strange! I am 186cm and ride 56cm frames, here it looks like the 53 has a 56 toptube. Thats a bit odd!
Any thoughts on this vs a alu Giant TCX?

by Weenie


kwakekeham
Posts: 87
Joined: Fri Jul 22, 2016 8:03 pm
Contact:

by kwakekeham

I just got this frame yesterday. The geometry is indeed weird but less so if you just look at virtual top tube length. They are using a kind of compact / hard tail mtb geometery and quoting sizing on seat tub. So they are large. I ordered the 50 and it's bigger than my 54cm madone and 55cm 80's wilier. I have confirmed with merlins that those numbers are legit. The head tubes are taller than I've seen on a lot of other gravel bikes putting you a little more upright.

I'm building it up myself , but on the component spec side the TCX SLR 2 is the price comparison point to this with Apex from merlins (giants about 200-300 more). Giant is a bit more "piece meal" to save money on their build side. Armchair analysis ensues:

It's hard to make seals that are compatible with both mineral oil and DOT fluid yet Giant is using their Conduct brakes on this SRAM (DOT) and other bikes with Shimano. That'a a strike against Giant (a big one in my opinion) because the seals may degrade with one of those setups. Merlin's uses APEX levers with Apex brakes. Simple

Giant is also using what looks like 140mm front and rear brakes. NOPE. I might be wrong but if I'm not since it's not listed. NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE. Unless you're 50kg. If you're about 75kg MIN is 160 front and 140 rear for road if you're not riding the plains, but really we should all be using 160's min in a gravel spec bike. I've speculated that flat mount will eventually get a revision (more standards!!!) bump to 180's as post mount dies on gravel spec.

Giant's using an FSA omega crankset. It's 1x but you tend to never find an FSA crankset as an "upgrade", but as OE cheaping out. I'd say with all the patent hub-bub years ago of SRAM getting litigious on their narrow wide patents, I'd say the cranks are probably about the same but the SRAM x-sync rings will be more reliable for chain drops.

The trade is that vertical compliance in the Giant is generated by seat stay and top tube offset and bend in that region while the merlins will be seat tube flex. So the giant kind of wins out here. But for the proprietary seat post they lost marks. Gravel's are usually peoples first bikes usually with lower spec due to risk of being beaten up. Going proprietary might hurt more in 5 - 7 years if you want to change anything.

On wheels it's ultra entry mavic's versus Giant house brand. I'd rather the mavics even if they are an OE spec. Both are 6 bolt, so minus points to both!

Giant more recognizable as a brand than Merlins. Merlins frame lists as fabricobbled in Taiwan so that's a plus. Welds are more visable as mentioned. Merlins has rack mounts (which I wanted) while giant doesn't (because TCX lists as cross?).

ooo
Posts: 769
Joined: Sat May 21, 2016 12:59 pm

by ooo

What is chainstay (and bb drop and wheel base) on merlin g1x?

Merlin also sell frameset and have weight info:
Weight: 2.4kg (53cm)

I hope this includes frame+fork
'

rides4beer
Posts: 141
Joined: Wed Nov 28, 2018 5:27 am
Location: SC

by rides4beer

kwakekeham wrote:
Thu Jul 11, 2019 3:34 pm
It's hard to make seals that are compatible with both mineral oil and DOT fluid yet Giant is using their Conduct brakes on this SRAM (DOT) and other bikes with Shimano. That'a a strike against Giant (a big one in my opinion) because the seals may degrade with one of those setups. Merlin's uses APEX levers with Apex brakes. Simple
FWIW, Giant has ditched the Conduct system for their 2020 models, full Shimano hyd now. :thumbup:

I would look at the Giant Revolt Advanced instead of the TCX, endurance/gravel geo and more tire clearance, love mine.

kwakekeham
Posts: 87
Joined: Fri Jul 22, 2016 8:03 pm
Contact:

by kwakekeham

rides4beer wrote:
Fri Jul 12, 2019 4:50 pm
FWIW, Giant has ditched the Conduct system for their 2020 models, full Shimano hyd now. :thumbup:
On the Canada and US sites there is only the 2019 TCX SLR in the same price range. The Advanced starts at 2500 USD for full apex, or over TWO Merlin Malt G1X's with similar equipment.... but then you're on a carbon gravel frame and not Aluminum.

So not sure where you get you're specs for 2020 if you mean SLR.

EDIT: Also Conduct isn't dead. List on Revolt Advanced 3 2020 gravel.

rides4beer
Posts: 141
Joined: Wed Nov 28, 2018 5:27 am
Location: SC

by rides4beer

kwakekeham wrote:
Sat Jul 13, 2019 12:26 am
On the Canada and US sites there is only the 2019 TCX SLR in the same price range. The Advanced starts at 2500 USD for full apex, or over TWO Merlin Malt G1X's with similar equipment.... but then you're on a carbon gravel frame and not Aluminum.

So not sure where you get you're specs for 2020 if you mean SLR.

EDIT: Also Conduct isn't dead. List on Revolt Advanced 3 2020 gravel.
Cool, the Advanced 3 is new, last I looked at the site, it didn't exist, 2 was the base level with full 105 hyd (it was also $2300, they bumped the price up some more, prob since they brough the 3 into the lineup). My shop told me they had ditched the Conduct system across all models, guess not.

by Weenie


Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post