When the Spanish fairy tale shattered — Lab test: the stiffness of the stems

Back by popular demand, the general all-things Road forum!

Moderator: robbosmans

User avatar
kiritozhang
Posts: 101
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2019 6:44 am
Contact:

by kiritozhang

OK here we come again. Since our first lab test on the stiffness of the integrated bars in 2019, we have then conducted the tests on the braking performance of the carbon wheels in the early 2020 and the stiffness of the drop bars in the mid 2020. Now it’s the time of the stems. What do you want to see next? Cranksets? Wind tunnels? Or others? Hahaha, it’s not a voting.

Back to the topic, we chose eight different stems including seven alloy ones which are easy to get and one super light carbon stem for reference, to study the stiffness on the different weight group. You may be disappointed if you’re aiming at some “rigid” stuff such as Pro Vibe Sprint and Zipp Sprint SL whose weight is around 200g, as they are designed to be as stiff as possible, which is not on our list.

Test list:

1, Extralite Hyperstem

Image
One of the top brands who aim at the weight. Compared to those Germany brands insisting on carbon fiber, Extralite ticks all their skill points on the alloy. Their products are usually seen on various super-light-built bikes. However, its remark is not that high. “Nothing else good but only light” is one of those remark.Is it really so?
Extralite has several different kinds of stems and our tested product is Hyperstem road, which offers normal size and OD2 size, with 0°, 6°, 12° and 18° choices and 40~120 mm length.
Image
The production rate and the import to China is extremely suppressed since Covid-19 pandemic. I couldn’t get any 110 mm one, so I used my own 120 mm one to test instead. Note that the weight is a bit heavier and the stiffness is a bit lower than the 110 mm one.
You need a Torx 20 tool to mount the stem instead of the normal T25 and follow the manual strictly, or you can easily break the stem. That’s $$$.
Last edited by kiritozhang on Fri Feb 05, 2021 4:31 am, edited 1 time in total.

by Weenie


Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓    Broad Selection ✓    Worldwide Delivery ✓

www.starbike.com



User avatar
kiritozhang
Posts: 101
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2019 6:44 am
Contact:

by kiritozhang

2, Deda Superleggera
Image
Another brand from Italy. The high-end products of Deda are not common in China, but there are a lot of Zero 100, since there are too many OEM products. Superleggera is one of their high-end production lines, including bar, stem and seatpost.
Image
Superleggera is actually very light weight if you don’t take those super light and super expensive products in consideration. The 110 mm one is only 109.5 g on my scale. The angle labelled on the stem is a bit special, 82°, which is effective to 8°, and it offers 80~140 mm.

3,UNO7
Image
The cheapest stem on our list, whose price is only a fraction of those big brands’ high-end products. I used an UNO stem on my S-works Tarmac SL4 when I was a student due to its price. However, I ditched it since its low stiffness. There are UNO 6 and 7, and the later one is better.
Image
UNO 7 offers 7° and 17°, 60~130 mm length. The 110 mm one is only 111 g on my scale, only 2 g heavier than Deda Superleggera. OK it’s 1.7 g to be honest. I have to mention that these are steel bolts. You can spend one or two dozen of dollars to shave down another 8~12 grams with 6 (hollow) Ti bolts, which nearly double the price.

4, FSA OS99 (Energy)
Image
The next one comes from the old big brand FSA, Full Speed Ahead. The top-end OS99 is updated to OS99-CSI now, which has a carbon reinforcement layer. The tested stem is OS99 alloy version, which is now the Energy series.
Image
OS99 has a simple design and only offers 6°, 80~130mm. The reason for its name OS99 is due to the weight. I forgot whether it was the 80 mm one or the 90 mm one to be 99 g. Its weight is on the average level, as it aims at the balance of both stiffness and the weight, and there are still quite a few Pros using this stem in the big tour, indicating that they are satisfied with the performance of it. This Energy series OS99 is 133 g on my scale.

Image
Image
Another big brand from Italy, 3T. OK nearly half of the tested stems come from Italia. Similar to FSA, you can see quite a lot 3T products in the big tour and they sponsor several teams. I have to say that 3T Ergonova drop bar is still being copied by the Chinese factory, and its shape is used for reference by some other brands: the “unique” bending and 77 mm reach.
ARX stems are also very classic and the carbon version, ARX LTD, has been copied to be an open mould. ARX2 is the second generation, which has a different set of bolts, and have two different production lines: white logo Pro level and red logo Team level. ARX2 team is one of the most used stems of Pros.
One of its issue is the T30 M6 bolt, which is used to locking itself on the steerer. Some mini torque tool sets don’t include this T30 bit.
Image
ARX2 Team offers 6° and 17°, 80~140 mm length. The weight is also on the average level. The 110 mm is 140 g on my scale.

6, Pro Vibe Alloy
Image
Pro is a brand in Netherland under Shimano Group and some people still call it Shimano. Another popular product in the big tour. Pro has Vibe Track and Vibe Sprint for those who need an extremely stiff stem. The carbon version is released in 2019, but most riders is still using the alloy version.
You can also choose OD2 version of it, and it offers -10° and -17°, 80~130 mm length. However, the 130 mm one seems not to be imported into China and I couldn’t order it in the Shimano system. Maybe it needs a special order.
You can not mount it in a positive angle since it uses a special top cap, and you need a special spacer if your steerer is too long, which is not elegant. The bolts of the stem cover are mounted from the backside. Some torque wrench may be too large to deal with them.
Image
The 110 mm is 150 g on my scale, and you have to use its heavy top cap. The OD2 version is several grams heavier.

7, Zipp Service Course SL
Image
The rival of Shimano on the other side of the Pacific —— SRAM. Note that Zipp is now under SRAM.
The style of this generation Service Course is different from the last version, sturdier. There are two different lines, SL and normal one.
Service Course SL offers 6° and 17° and also OD2 version. The longest is 150 mm but is hard to get.
Image
The 110 mm one is 159g on my scale. Emm… It’s the heaviest one in this test, though it is called SL. It is really Zipp style —— The weight is always the last to be considered. One Service Course SL is almost twice the weight of the Hyperstem road.
Last edited by kiritozhang on Fri Feb 05, 2021 4:39 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
kiritozhang
Posts: 101
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2019 6:44 am
Contact:

by kiritozhang

8. Darimo IX2
Image
Darimo is a brand from Spain, whose products are famous for its extremely light weight. The most famous product is neither the bar nor the stem, but its seatpost T1 loop. Moreover, they custom make the special seatpost for different bikes such as specialized for those who want a lighter one.
There are two different models of its stem: IX2 and IX4. As the name suggests, IX2 uses two bolts to lock the front cap while IX4 uses four. You can only choose IX4 to pair with an aero drop bar. IX2 also offers OD2 size and the weight is almost the same with the normal one. It offers 6°, 12°, 17° and 25°, 60~130 mm length.
Image
I have two different IX2 stems, one 6° 100 mm and the other one 12° 120 mm. I chose the 100 mm one to test as the shorter the stiffer.
The steerer mounting part (stack), which is 46 mm, is higher than the other stems in this test, maybe because it is glued together. Check your steerer length before ordering this stem. You can not over torque and if your steerer is not long enough, the stem can be loosened under duty. The 100 mm one is 71 g on my scale, and it is not suggested for those who are heavier than 90 kg.
Image
*f##k* luck.There was a defective screw on the stem.This is not a second-hand product, but a first-hand user.
Last edited by kiritozhang on Fri Feb 05, 2021 4:43 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
kiritozhang
Posts: 101
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2019 6:44 am
Contact:

by kiritozhang

Image
Method
Seems familiar right? Yes, it is still that machine used in our previous test of the bars. We applied 30 kgf force in a fixed distance on one side both upwards and downwards and tested dozens of times to get a weighted average value.
We have cooperated with a factory of a certain Tour de France brand, so we can use various equipment in the factory.
Since the method may be different from other tests, it is not suggested to compare our results with others directly.

Results
Image
Image
Image
Image
Conclusion
Note that stiffness to weight ratio only counts when the stiffness is enough for you.
1, The stiffness of Extralite Hyperstem, Deda Superleggera and UNO 7 is on the same level. I have to respect the ability of Extralite. Its light weight and the stiffness make it worth that price, while Deda Superleggera is the most embarrassing one: it is only 1.7 g lighter than UNO 7, but its stiffness is only a tad higher.
If only take Superleggera and UNO 7 into consideration, UNO 7 has an absolute advantage due to its price, and even you spend some dollars on Ti bolts. However, quite a lot riders feel that the stiffness of these three stems is not enough, and I suggest these for those who are not heavy or just ride for fun. Note that the longer stem has a lower stiffness. These are definitely not for those sprinters.
2, According to the riders’ feed back and our lab test, I think FSA and 3T have redesigned and tested their stems quite a few times before their release. These two stems from FSA and 3T are at the sweet point of the weight and the stiffness, and the performance should be enough for over 90% riders. It is similar to the bar, the frame and the wheel, as one may neither ask for an extremely high stiffness, nor not too low.
3, Pro Vibe alloy and Zipp Service Course SL though have an excellent stiffness, they are a bit too heavy. Maybe only 0.1% rider can feel noodle when they use these one of these two stems. These two stems are for those who want an excellent stiffness but don’t what to pay $$$ for the top-end (heavy) carbon stem such as Zipp Sprint SL. The stiffness to weight ratio is around 3 N/mm/g for the alloy stems in our test, except Extralite.
The torsional stiffness of Darimo IX2 is way to low. I don’t know if it is due to its low-cost glue-together craft instead of one mould. Its stiffness to weight ratio is lower than Extralite Hyperstem road and its stiffness is way lower, but it calls for a higher price. I can only suggest this stem to those “scale-player” without any performance requirement.
Last edited by kiritozhang on Fri Feb 05, 2021 4:32 am, edited 1 time in total.

Aeo
Posts: 682
Joined: Wed May 25, 2016 2:06 am

by Aeo

Ritchey WCS C260 100mm 103g
Ritchey Superlogic C260 110mm 125g
Giant TCR Adv Pro Disc '17 · BH Lynx Race Evo '19 · Seraph GR029 '21 · Canyon Inflite AL '14

Maddie
Posts: 1547
Joined: Tue Oct 17, 2017 5:44 am

by Maddie

Very interesting as usual, Kiritozhang!

1llum4
Posts: 303
Joined: Thu Jul 12, 2018 6:00 am

by 1llum4

Thank you very much for those tests Kiritozhang . It's one thing I loved about Fariwheels Bikes was those stiffness test. Any chance you can get your hand on a MCFK stem to test ?

kode54
Posts: 3755
Joined: Tue May 23, 2006 9:39 pm

by kode54

Great comparison test. However, I'm surprised Enve, Bontrager and THM was not included in this test.
- Factor Ostro VAM Disc
- Factor LS Disc
- Specialized Aethos Disc
- Sturdy Ti Allroad Disc
- Guru Praemio R Disc

User avatar
neeb
Posts: 1102
Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2009 8:19 pm

by neeb

The torsional stiffness of Darimo IX2 is way to low. I don’t know if it is due to its low-cost glue-together craft instead of one mould. Its stiffness to weight ratio is lower than Extralite Hyperstem road and its stiffness is way lower, but it calls for a higher price. I can only suggest this stem to those “scale-player” without any performance requirement.
Darimo still scores very well on stiffness to weight ratio, and if you have no need of mega-stiffness in a stem it's still the lightest by quite a long way. Also (this may or may not be superstition), I personally feel more comfortable mating carbon stems with lightweight carbon bars and steerer tubes, there seems to be less chance of damage from imprinting / compression, especially where you have very wide clamping areas as with the Darimo.

"low-cost glue-together" is very unfair - it's a handmade product made by experts in CF that pushes the limits of the material.

I guess it's not one for the sprinters but personally I've never found stem stiffness an issue. I'm 63kg and have never sprinted at more than 900w in my life though..

RDY
Posts: 2422
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2020 10:31 pm

by RDY

Bear in mind that Darimo specifically state that they will reinforce any of their products if you are over or around the weight limit, or just want something stiffer.

Would have been curious to see how the Schmolke / THM stems compared to the Darimo.

Also if you're not caning it or hugely heavy or powerful, the Darimo is likely to transmit less vibration than the Extralite - it's carbon and it's less stiff - which some may prefer.
Last edited by RDY on Wed Feb 03, 2021 8:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Hexsense
Posts: 3289
Joined: Wed Dec 30, 2015 12:41 am
Location: USA

by Hexsense

neeb wrote:
Wed Feb 03, 2021 6:24 pm
Darimo still scores very well on stiffness to weight ratio, and if you have no need of mega-stiffness in a stem it's still the lightest by quite a long way. (of over 10g if we compare 100mm vs 100mm rather than 120mm extralite)

"low-cost glue-together" is very unfair - it's a handmade product made by experts in CF that pushes the limits of the material.

personally I've never found stem stiffness an issue. I'm 63kg and have never sprinted at more than 900w in my life though..
Okay, with all the positive sides you argue, your choice of stem is justified. I hope you feel better with your purchase.

@kiritozhang
Not interested in house brand that is also popular aftermarket?
-Bontrager Blendr Pro stem -- 140g-ish, for its Blendr computer and accessories mount. See if heavily cut out stem faceplate (to make room for Blendr mount) effect its stiffness.
-Specialized S-works SL stem -- 130g-ish, for its shiny black surface and S-works snobs.

calleking
Posts: 388
Joined: Sun Sep 13, 2015 3:20 pm

by calleking

Thanks for the interesting test results! Great stuff.

I have the Xtralite Hyperstem 120mm and I'm actually suprisingly happy with the stiffness. It is superlight but the bolts and the construction at the front do make me a bit nervous. Should probably switch it out since I do race a bit and I'm not the lightest rider at 75kg (not a sprinter).
2023 Wilier Rave SLR
2022 Wilier Filante SLR
2021 Cannondale Scalpel Carbon 2

User avatar
micky
Posts: 5765
Joined: Thu Sep 21, 2006 8:57 pm
Location: Vicenza
Contact:

by micky

Great review as usual!

It would be interesting to compare an Extralite 110 with the values of the 120 to see how much difference there's in terms of stiffness.

User avatar
kiritozhang
Posts: 101
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2019 6:44 am
Contact:

by kiritozhang

neeb wrote:
Wed Feb 03, 2021 6:24 pm
The torsional stiffness of Darimo IX2 is way to low. I don’t know if it is due to its low-cost glue-together craft instead of one mould. Its stiffness to weight ratio is lower than Extralite Hyperstem road and its stiffness is way lower, but it calls for a higher price. I can only suggest this stem to those “scale-player” without any performance requirement.
Darimo still scores very well on stiffness to weight ratio, and if you have no need of mega-stiffness in a stem it's still the lightest by quite a long way. Also (this may or may not be superstition), I personally feel more comfortable mating carbon stems with lightweight carbon bars and steerer tubes, there seems to be less chance of damage from imprinting / compression, especially where you have very wide clamping areas as with the Darimo.

"low-cost glue-together" is very unfair - it's a handmade product made by experts in CF that pushes the limits of the material.

I guess it's not one for the sprinters but personally I've never found stem stiffness an issue. I'm 63kg and have never sprinted at more than 900w in my life though..
I personally do not approve of this craft. This is an approach to reduce costs and mold costs.
Whether in the handlebar or the frame, the one-piece molding process that reduces splicing can provide better stiffness and strength.
If an ultra-light rim or handlebar is produced using splicing technology, then whether it is produced by ordinary workers or masters, the performance will be worse.

User avatar
kiritozhang
Posts: 101
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2019 6:44 am
Contact:

by kiritozhang

RDY wrote:
Wed Feb 03, 2021 7:32 pm
Bear in mind that Darimo specifically state that they will reinforce any of their products if you are over or around the weight limit, or just want something stiffer.

Would have been curious to see how the Schmolke / THM stems compared to the Darimo.

Also if you're not caning it or hugely heavy or powerful, the Darimo is likely to transmit less vibration than the Extralite - it's carbon and it's less stiff - which some may prefer.
Ritchey does not have an agent in China, it is difficult for me to buy it.
May test s-works sl and bontrager, schmolke, mcfk next time.

by Weenie


Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓    Broad Selection ✓    Worldwide Delivery ✓

www.starbike.com



Post Reply