Understeer Whilst Cornering
Moderator: robbosmans
I feel a lot of people here are over thinking decending and cornering. If you lead with your head and shoulders and look at forward at where you want to go, that is where your bike is going, plain and simple. Learning a proper line is also important. I watched a rider pedal strike and crash in front of me on a fast 90* left hand turn in a crit. He was on the front and his line was horrible. I proceeded to pedal through that corner on every lap except for the lap I attacked and took the corner at 33mph. It does take expericence and commitment to corner and decend quickly but it is no where near as complicated as you guys are making it out to be.
State Bicycle Co. Undefeated: viewtopic.php?f=10&t=171358
Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓ Broad Selection ✓ Worldwide Delivery ✓
www.starbike.com
- cyclespeed
- Posts: 1134
- Joined: Mon Jun 06, 2016 8:45 am
+1 on this ^^timmerrr wrote: ↑Mon Sep 09, 2019 6:44 pmI feel a lot of people here are over thinking decending and cornering. If you lead with your head and shoulders and look at forward at where you want to go, that is where your bike is going, plain and simple. Learning a proper line is also important. I watched a rider pedal strike and crash in front of me on a fast 90* left hand turn in a crit. He was on the front and his line was horrible. I proceeded to pedal through that corner on every lap except for the lap I attacked and took the corner at 33mph. It does take expericence and commitment to corner and decend quickly but it is no where near as complicated as you guys are making it out to be.
I would say 70% of it is picking the right line, 20% braking properly (i.e. hard and in a straight line), and 10% all the other little bits and bobs.
Look up Cyclespeed Descending on Youtube for some basic tips
So? What does that mean?
So how does that advice help the OP with his problem?You push on the outside of the bar to stay upright while cornering, not to steer through it.
We're not riding reverse steering bikes, they're irrelevant, all you're doing is conflating years upon years of ingrained habits and "intuition."
It's a little baffling that you say something I commonly do isn't possible...maybe it's something you should try.
You literally just said your method makes the bike want to stand up. Now you’re saying your method is how you lean the bike hard. That’s why it’s confusing.
That, and there is absolutely no physical reason why your method would make the front wheel any more resistant to sliding out.
No, I am not saying you can’t corner by moving your weight, I am saying that learning to ride a bike is done by learning to countersteer intuitively and that you do it all the time but refuse to use it to go round corners. I have had this discussion with many cyclists (and motorcyclists) who all agree this is the way to go once they think it through and try it. Most are very surprised how easy and fast it makes moving the bike, especially in situations like opening car doors and such.TheRich wrote: ↑Tue Sep 10, 2019 12:02 amWe're not riding reverse steering bikes, they're irrelevant, all you're doing is conflating years upon years of ingrained habits and "intuition."
It's a little baffling that you say something I commonly do isn't possible...maybe it's something you should try.
it’s a free world, just do what you want - why don’t you give it a try on your next ride anyway and see how it works for you?
+1 someone making sense in this thread.timmerrr wrote: ↑Mon Sep 09, 2019 6:44 pmI feel a lot of people here are over thinking decending and cornering. If you lead with your head and shoulders and look at forward at where you want to go, that is where your bike is going, plain and simple. Learning a proper line is also important. I watched a rider pedal strike and crash in front of me on a fast 90* left hand turn in a crit. He was on the front and his line was horrible. I proceeded to pedal through that corner on every lap except for the lap I attacked and took the corner at 33mph. It does take expericence and commitment to corner and decend quickly but it is no where near as complicated as you guys are making it out to be.
Some people talking about counter-steering and reverse counter-steering, completely overthinking it.
It's pretty much like golf, you just set-up and then you take your shot. Over-thinking it will cause you get too tense and air swipe or shank it top it or slice it. Just learn to knee-down a motorcycle on a closed road or track and then apply that mental strategy and total relaxed confidence to the road cycling. BTW I have followed and been followed by pros and neo-pros on very complex descents in Tenerife, Majorca and Gran Canaria and they aren't any quicker than I am.
- cyclespeed
- Posts: 1134
- Joined: Mon Jun 06, 2016 8:45 am
I used to cycle guide quite a bit, in the Alps and Mallorca and very often the level of descending was very poor, simply because the riders in question had little experience in the mountains.
So, as on this thread, they tend to look for a kind of magic solution, some 'counter-steer' technique that will suddenly make them great descenders. It doesn't really work like that. A bicycle is very light and you just lean into the bend and look where you want to go.
You just have to practice, don't tense up and let yourself and your body learn how to descend. There are some good tips to help riders improve, but basically the more you ride mountains, the better you will get.
So, as on this thread, they tend to look for a kind of magic solution, some 'counter-steer' technique that will suddenly make them great descenders. It doesn't really work like that. A bicycle is very light and you just lean into the bend and look where you want to go.
You just have to practice, don't tense up and let yourself and your body learn how to descend. There are some good tips to help riders improve, but basically the more you ride mountains, the better you will get.
Vehicles with inline wheels turn by leaning. The way this works is an alteration and stabilisation of various forces, including centripetal, gravitational and frictional forces.
Countersteering will cause the bike to lean, as it temporarily creates an imbalance that the bike will counteract by leaning in the direction opposite the steering input. A bicycle is usually so light that it is fairly easy to make it lean simply by shifting weight. Unlike a motorcycle, which has so much more gyroscopic force given the fast spinning, heavy components and higher traveling speed that it simply isn't near efficient enough to make it lean any other way than via countersteering. (Those other ways still apply, but they just have much more limited effect on a motorcycle for the reasons indicated.)
When they lean, all two-wheeled vehicles self-correct the steering in the direction of the turn, at an angle determined by various factors including weight and its distribution, speed, steering angle, trail, etc.
This self-correction of the steering is essential to maintain the stability and correct arc of the vehicle through the turn. Try overtightening your stem stop cap to restrict the free movement of the bars on your bike and see how scary to ride it becomes.
We all subconsciously do what's necessary to cause the bike to turn and let it stabilized after the steering input. I think the more important take away is what the rider can do to maintain ideal traction and stability through the turn to allow the bicycle to do its thing under optimal traction and stability conditions.
Distribute weight evenly front to rear. Keep weight low, over the bike. Weight the outside pedal. Look though the turn for the vanishing point, or exit point if visible.
All this will maximise available traction and will allow the bicycle to turn optimally. That optimum level will vary as a function of bike geometry, tires, compliance, stiffness, etc.
Countersteering will cause the bike to lean, as it temporarily creates an imbalance that the bike will counteract by leaning in the direction opposite the steering input. A bicycle is usually so light that it is fairly easy to make it lean simply by shifting weight. Unlike a motorcycle, which has so much more gyroscopic force given the fast spinning, heavy components and higher traveling speed that it simply isn't near efficient enough to make it lean any other way than via countersteering. (Those other ways still apply, but they just have much more limited effect on a motorcycle for the reasons indicated.)
When they lean, all two-wheeled vehicles self-correct the steering in the direction of the turn, at an angle determined by various factors including weight and its distribution, speed, steering angle, trail, etc.
This self-correction of the steering is essential to maintain the stability and correct arc of the vehicle through the turn. Try overtightening your stem stop cap to restrict the free movement of the bars on your bike and see how scary to ride it becomes.
We all subconsciously do what's necessary to cause the bike to turn and let it stabilized after the steering input. I think the more important take away is what the rider can do to maintain ideal traction and stability through the turn to allow the bicycle to do its thing under optimal traction and stability conditions.
Distribute weight evenly front to rear. Keep weight low, over the bike. Weight the outside pedal. Look though the turn for the vanishing point, or exit point if visible.
All this will maximise available traction and will allow the bicycle to turn optimally. That optimum level will vary as a function of bike geometry, tires, compliance, stiffness, etc.
I'm genuinely confused as to why you're projecting your refusal to accept that a different technique actually works onto me.drhex wrote: ↑Tue Sep 10, 2019 7:15 amNo, I am not saying you can’t corner by moving your weight, I am saying that learning to ride a bike is done by learning to countersteer intuitively and that you do it all the time but refuse to use it to go round corners. I have had this discussion with many cyclists (and motorcyclists) who all agree this is the way to go once they think it through and try it. Most are very surprised how easy and fast it makes moving the bike, especially in situations like opening car doors and such.
it’s a free world, just do what you want - why don’t you give it a try on your next ride anyway and see how it works for you?
Wow. 4 pages on how to corner. Just practice. Unless you have a mental block (and some people do -- nothing wrong with that), practice will make perfect!
“If you save your breath I feel a man like you can manage it. And if you don't manage it, you'll die. Only slowly, very slowly, old friend.”