Tarmac sl6 vs Madone
Moderator: robbosmans
Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓ Broad Selection ✓ Worldwide Delivery ✓
www.starbike.com
I’ve just switched from Madone 9 H2 to a SLR H1.5 with low stem (i.e. H1 fit).
The old Madone definitely felt like I was violently shaking a big sail at the front sometimes when climbing out of the saddle. It was just too big in the headtube length to feel nimble.
The SLR is much better.
It still is not as nimble as my Emonda but the latter has 900g tubs on it and is solely built for climbing. In addition. the variable/aero stem and new ion light are chunkier and heavier. Once spring summer arrives I’ll be back to just Garmin with or without Go Pro.
As for comfort the SLR is more comfy than the 9. I have it on the comfiest setting and slammed my stem arrangement and concentrated on rotating the pelvis down when on flat/chaingang type rides. No back issues despite the more extreme position.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The old Madone definitely felt like I was violently shaking a big sail at the front sometimes when climbing out of the saddle. It was just too big in the headtube length to feel nimble.
The SLR is much better.
It still is not as nimble as my Emonda but the latter has 900g tubs on it and is solely built for climbing. In addition. the variable/aero stem and new ion light are chunkier and heavier. Once spring summer arrives I’ll be back to just Garmin with or without Go Pro.
As for comfort the SLR is more comfy than the 9. I have it on the comfiest setting and slammed my stem arrangement and concentrated on rotating the pelvis down when on flat/chaingang type rides. No back issues despite the more extreme position.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Did you have to change anything fit wise between Madone and tarmac? I’m 56 Madone (and my emonda when I had it) with 90mm stem currently. Curious if I would be the same or diff on tarmac
First time out on the SLR I had it on the stiffest setting and it was very similar to 9. Since then tried it on comfy position.
Unsure if I’ll go back as it feels great. I tilted the saddle a touch lower and slammed the stem. Felt so different in terms of position there was concern in my mind I had gone too far. However, the lack of vibration and overall comfort has been fantastic.
I’ve nearly always been a 58. I have practised over years on getting a straighter back posture on the bike and rotating the hips - this has allowed me to become a bit more ‘aggressive’ in that in my latest fit I was encouraged to bring saddle forward and get a lower, 130mm stem.
The only time I went away from a 58cm was getting the Scott Foil in a 56cm size. I used a long 130 stem then. This was mainly due to 58cm frames being out of stock when I ordered. However, in retrospect it worked out well. The Foil frame felt very stiff and the long seat post added some suspension/flexibility.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Unsure if I’ll go back as it feels great. I tilted the saddle a touch lower and slammed the stem. Felt so different in terms of position there was concern in my mind I had gone too far. However, the lack of vibration and overall comfort has been fantastic.
I’ve nearly always been a 58. I have practised over years on getting a straighter back posture on the bike and rotating the hips - this has allowed me to become a bit more ‘aggressive’ in that in my latest fit I was encouraged to bring saddle forward and get a lower, 130mm stem.
The only time I went away from a 58cm was getting the Scott Foil in a 56cm size. I used a long 130 stem then. This was mainly due to 58cm frames being out of stock when I ordered. However, in retrospect it worked out well. The Foil frame felt very stiff and the long seat post added some suspension/flexibility.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 1:28 am
Any conclusions here. I am looking at same options. Madone SLR 8 or Tarmac SL6 Ultralight. Decisions. Rolling hills here in Austin so not even sure which bike works better in my area.
What size are you?Toothengineer wrote:Any conclusions here. I am looking at same options. Madone SLR 8 or Tarmac SL6 Ultralight. Decisions. Rolling hills here in Austin so not even sure which bike works better in my area.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 1:28 am
I could ride a 54 or 56 of either bike. I am looking at a Madone SLR7 or a Tarmac SL6 Ultralight.
Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓ Broad Selection ✓ Worldwide Delivery ✓
www.starbike.com
As Sychen says it depends on you and your frame not the bike frame size.Toothengineer wrote:I could ride a 54 or 56 of either bike. I am looking at a Madone SLR7 or a Tarmac SL6 Ultralight.
If you were a skinny mountain goat then play to your strengths and get a climbing machine. If you (like me) are a somewhat generous build then I’m never going to climb like Contador. At that point I am out of the saddle a lot and go for the aero for the bigger/stiffer BB area.
Where do you get most of your enjoyment from ? In or out of saddle? It’s the biggest smile on your face we are chasing - not Strava KOM’s (although there may be a correlation).
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk