ScottinFL wrote: ↑Thu Nov 08, 2018 10:41 pm
^^^ Wow, stunning. Especially in that light.
I will say that the reviews seem to be spot on. Their assessment of the Venge is exactly my observation as well -- very quick handling, very light feeling, and quick/stiff everywhere it needs to be. A lively and competitive ride for experienced riders.
One thing I thought a bit interesting was the knock on the 'Dale SS for being overweight but no mention of the Trek's weight, which is nearly identical.
Still can't believe that BMC Timemachine Road and 'Velo S5 are in such late release. I feel like they may have missed a good opportunity by not releasing their 2019 models when everyone else did (i.e. right around the TDF). I for one was interested in both but eventually gave up waiting.
I wanted to have a second look at this review, and to be honest I find it hard to believe this not being a Trek advert.
Aside from the weight, the writers clearly ignored/minimised issues such as the Madone's weight and the lack of practicality (proprietary stem and handlebar) compared to the other two, while exaggerating minimal problems with the others.
For example, in the final wrap up, Madone's cons do not mention weight and include "it is no longer in our garage".. In the conclusion they don't even mention the lack of a powermeter (which they did address partially earlier on..).
On the Venge, one can read more cons, which are in most cases laughable, such as "rounded crank shape doesn't match the angular shapes of the frame" - I don't think I need to say more on this. Or, "tire puncure protection".. As if that was a big issue seemingly unsolvable.. Specialized's tire puncure resistance is worth mentioning in the conclusion, but Trek's lack of a PM isn't. Oookay.
Finally, the language is clearly aimed at making the Madone look better. While Trek "manages to keep the weight at 7.63", Cannondale with 30 more gram "is the heaviest", with "slow acceleration". Despite a jungle of proprietary parts, Trek is a "masterpiece of engineering" and suitable for everybody, while Cannondale "saves a few watts", and is for "the speed junkies".
I don't know, probably the Madone may be the best bike out there, but I find this review to be biased.