shinyboy wrote:Not really sure how this will help you but -
my saddle height is 81.5cm - handlebars are 16cm lower.
Whoa. That's a crazy drop!
Moderator: robbosmans
CharlesM wrote:there is no right answer for this.
Go see a fitter
CharlesM wrote:Seriously...
The ONLY other answer would be to find someone with your exact same body measures, flexibility, pedal stroke and personal injury past and age and fitness. And then it would be no better than a coin toss that you will want the same feel and have the same riding style.
Everything else but seeing a qualified fitter is bullsh!t.
shinyboy wrote:Do you really believe sitting on a bike is so complicated that you need to hand over a wad of cash for some bloke to tell you how to do it
Look at how the people who push road bikes to their limits at the highest level set up their bikes and fit on their bikes. It's pretty consistent.
There is a fairly narrow range of hip angle that allows the glutes to work....road bike position is what it is because it works and any intelligent adult should be able to assimilate this to a position that works for them.
SL58 wrote:It is really very simple: take a -17deg. stem and slam it.
fa63 wrote:shinyboy wrote:Do you really believe sitting on a bike is so complicated that you need to hand over a wad of cash for some bloke to tell you how to do it
Look at how the people who push road bikes to their limits at the highest level set up their bikes and fit on their bikes. It's pretty consistent.
There is a fairly narrow range of hip angle that allows the glutes to work....road bike position is what it is because it works and any intelligent adult should be able to assimilate this to a position that works for them.
I have been compiling published information on the fit of pro riders and their bikes for a while now. I just put up the results here:
http://ft-atalay.blogspot.com/2012/03/pro-bike-fit.html
As you can see, there seems to be a decent correlation between rider height vs. saddle height and "reach", but a poor correlation between rider height vs. "stack".
Besides this general observation, I will let everyone draw their own conclusions from this chart.
fa63 wrote:shinyboy wrote:Do you really believe sitting on a bike is so complicated that you need to hand over a wad of cash for some bloke to tell you how to do it
Look at how the people who push road bikes to their limits at the highest level set up their bikes and fit on their bikes. It's pretty consistent.
There is a fairly narrow range of hip angle that allows the glutes to work....road bike position is what it is because it works and any intelligent adult should be able to assimilate this to a position that works for them.
I have been compiling published information on the fit of pro riders and their bikes for a while now. I just put up the results here:
http://ft-atalay.blogspot.com/2012/03/pro-bike-fit.html
As you can see, there seems to be a decent correlation between rider height vs. saddle height and "reach", but a poor correlation between rider height vs. "stack".
Besides this general observation, I will let everyone draw their own conclusions from this chart.