TobinHatesYou wrote: ↑Thu Dec 05, 2024 2:41 pm
cyclespeed wrote: ↑Thu Dec 05, 2024 9:33 am
It's all gone a bit quiet here since the Aerocoach testing......
Parcours showed similar results back in August. I maintain that this is a great option for any windy mass-start race day where the field gets blown apart as soon as it turns onto a crosswind sector. Also in TT terms, the importance of stability even on relatively calm days with occasional gusts can’t be understated. You may end up with 4W more of rolling resistance, but if wind makes you squirm and ease off pedals, that’s also going to kill your average.
The aero difference between the 111 and the TT in Xavier's testing is much less out to 15 degrees than what Parcours show, though he doesn't go past 15. It does suggest that the differences are wheel dependent, but on that specific wheel the tires are basically equal out to 15 degrees.
My highest recorded 20 minute power and my lowest recorded CxA where with a Blackwell 100 with a 20mm Veloflex in super heavy crosswinds in a 12.5 mile TT. I can only describe it as terrifying... But, it didn't impact my drag numbers or my power output (or the result). Granted, the wind contributed to the low drag, and of course I may have gone even faster with as more stable front wheel... But I personally have never had a front wheel affect my power output in a TT, and I've done some windy ones. Ultimately, testing it in real world conditions is the only way to be sure. I'm curious about the tire and definitely plan to test one out.
What I do know however is that it's difficult to overcome a Crr penalty in most instances, since the deficit is there all of the time. And when I look back specifically at race files that had crosswind selections, the speeds where those selections happen are generally low enough that the TT is still a faster option.
The TT is about 3-3.5 W slower at 48 kph at >10 degrees on Parcour's wheel. That's a pretty thin margin in some pretty unusual stances. The differences are much less in the Aerocoach data.
Funny thing is I do see a potential use case for the 111, but I see it differently than you. A windy mountain race seems like a good potential option. You can use a shallower wheel and still get solid aero performance, good handling, and the Crr penalty is reduced a bit since you're either climbing (less weight on the front wheel) or descending (where the grip and stability can't help). The question for me will be "how much more aero will it be on my front wheel".