Thanks! I'm looking into the cost for a small run. I've done stuff like this before (custom short pull arms for TRP HY/RDs among other things). I like the idea of having the option to use either 15mm or 12mm wheels without any special hub parts. I should know whether or not it is worth my time and effort to move forward in a few days when the factory gets back to me with a price.spud wrote: ↑Sun Dec 31, 2017 9:05 pmthat's a VERY NICE solution. Custom machining would be pricey though. My original hope was to use a stock timesert or something like it, and simply bond in a bushing to the DR side. Maybe someone will do a run of these parts, but I wouldn't hold my breath. I could just buy a new fork for $200.
Moderator: Moderator Team
Shimano 12x100 thru-axle standards (no 15x100):
http://productinfo.shimano.com/#/spec/2 ... xle%20(AX)
Sram 12x100 and 15x100 thru-axle standards:
Yeah, it might be best to just go solid there rather than try and weight weenie this part. I can let the end user decide if they really want to tune that area to shave a few grams. I need to make a few refinements are taking some more accurate measurements and then do another weight check.
The pricing will stand provided that I don't uncover any unknowns that make this adapter set not work as intended.
To that end, can you confirm a few things for me?
1. What is the thickness of your dropout tabs where the thru axle passes through?
2. Is the threaded dropout fully tapped or is it counterbored to 15mm on the inside for some distance?
3. What the outer diameter of the end caps on the 12mm thru axle wheelset that you want to use?
This last one is the most critical and something I had overlooked initially. The 12mm end caps for my Bitex hubs use the same OD as the 15mm end caps but I am wondering if this is always going to be the case. If 12mm end caps for other wheels are not larger than 15mm (ideally 17mm or more) they won't have any bearing surface against a 15mm thru axle fork dropout. And in that case, this adapter set won't work, and I don't believe there are any good workarounds either.
The current end cap OD for 15mm is 21mm. The end cap for the 12mm is 19mm. Clearly a difference there. I do wonder how much of the axle load is carried by the through axle (into the dropout) vs via the end cap into the fork. Part of me says that the shoulder made in carbon is probably not very precise, and the wheel is really located by the axle. This is certainly born out in that the wheel needs to be wiggled a tiny bit on the threaded side to get the axle to engage the threads.
As a separate observation, using a bolt head axle means substantial torque will be transmitted to the insert thread, which probably means it will need to be secured in the dropout. A clamping quick release removes that torque load, though is obviously much more involved to manufacture.
Given that at least one set of 12mm end caps are large enough to utilize the same clamping/bearing surface as 15mm end caps I am hopeful that this adapter kit still makes sense. It does sound like installing a 12mm wheel might take a little extra care as those shoulders in the fork ends won't provide any alignment help. No big deal for me as I don't race and rarely remove my wheels.
If I am still not making sense I can create a sketch to help explain what my words are likely failing to.
As far as the thread adapter being subject to torque when used with a flush, tool-driven, thru axle, I am thinking that the little holes and a spanner wrench will allow it to be installed securely enough that it won't back out when installing the axle. Perhaps some Teflon tape or a small drop of thread locker will do the trick if torque alone doesn't.
Ok cool. Do your dropout thickness measurements include those alignment shoulders or not? I need the dimension without. I still need to inspect my own fork and do some online digging for as many fork geometries as I can find. Hoping there is a common set of dimensions to which 15mm road forks have been designed.
Thanks for confirming. And yeah, for some of us it's no big deal but I'd rather play it safe leaving it a few tenths of a millimeter short and avoid any potential issues or complaints (you know, from the millions and millions who will buy this adapter set ). I need to leave the shoulder on the thru axle short, too, for the same reason.
- Similar Topics
- Last post
- 1 Replies
- 258 Views
Last post by Martin.F
Thu Mar 22, 2018 5:04 pm
- 1 Replies
- 304 Views
Last post by stormur
Sat Jan 06, 2018 8:21 pm
- 9 Replies
- 1381 Views
Last post by Noctiluxx
Sun Jan 28, 2018 7:05 am
- 8 Replies
- 1038 Views
Last post by Disc0
Wed Nov 08, 2017 12:59 am
- 7 Replies
- 580 Views
Last post by ms6073
Wed Dec 13, 2017 12:42 pm