CARBON CRANKS

Discuss light weight issues concerning road bikes & parts.
Post Reply
User avatar
fester
Posts: 41
Joined: Fri May 28, 2004 10:20 am
Location: Worcester, South Africa

by fester

Hi there all you experts.

I'm looking to upgrade my current cranks. (Campy Chorus carbon cranks and Chorus BB). I have a pending warranty claim, so I'm going to have them replaced.

I'm interested in either of the following:
CAMPY RECORD
FSA SUPERLIGHT
NEW ZIPP 400 CRANKS
STRONGLIGHT PULSION

or any other suggestions.

I'm looking for a significant saving in weight and improvement in stiffness, else I'll just replace them with another set of Chorus cranks

Thanks for any input

Cheers
Francois

P.S. I finally got my very own ZERO GRAVITY brakes yesterday. They are AWESOME and incredibly light!
_________________
WHAT MAKES A GREAT CYCLIST?
The enviable capacity to loose all
perspective and become fanatical.

by Weenie


Sargon
Posts: 4
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 3:53 am
Location: Folsom, CA

by Sargon

Hi Fester,

A few thoughts.

BB interface is an important factor in the decision. Depending on how much you ride, it may make little difference or be a monumental factor.

ISIS - Becoming increasingly available. Some nice cranks are only available with this interface (Zipp, Pulsion). Due to the desire to create a non-proprietary super stiff spindle, the spec did not allow for bearings big enough to ensure good/great durability. The bearing diameter is 2mm, roughly the same size as a 14ga spoke. You will see people disagree on the durability of ISIS, but I also know of no pro racers (or riders who do very high volume) who haven't had problems. This is why companies like Phil Wood, or even Chris King, who was one of the three original manufacturers to endorse ISIS, have not come to market with an ISIS BB. Ceramic bearings have been suggested as a solution. IMO, ceramics are pretty much pointless in a BB, rpms are too low and they are more prone to contamination than anywhere else on the bike. The benefits to ceramic have little to no payoff for normal cycling. Ceramics are sometimes used for track and wheelchair hubs in the Olympics etc. where low drag, no lubrication, and maximum acceleration are key, and price is irrelevant.

Octalink - The Ultegra is a good, very durable, albeit heavy, BB. The lighter Dura-Ace can work well too, but does require more frequent maintenance to perform optimally. From a WW standpoint, the Ultegra is quite heavy, and the Dura-Ace is moderately light.

Square taper - An old standard. Nothing wonderful about it, except that it allows for the use of some great (super durable) BB's, such as the Phil Ti, or Am Classic Ti. For perspective, I had an old Phil Stainless Steel BB that had over 20,000 miles on it with one re-greasing and the bearings were still smooth.

Outboard bearings - Becoming more popular. From a design perspective, this is probably the way to go. It places the bearings as far out on the spindle as possible (helping stiffness), and allows for very large, durable bearings. The only problem is that most of the lightest cranks are not offered in this interface (yet). I believe that the THM-Carbones Clavicula is a notable exception. This may well be the ultimate WW crank/BB combo.

You might also consider the Storck Power Arms, which are very light and available in many of the BB types. That was going to be my choice, but a Cat Carbon crank became available, so being a good WW I snagged it and got a Phil Ti BB to go along. This combo will be very light, and should provide very high reliability and long service.
California does have its faults.

blackthunder
Posts: 61
Joined: Tue Jan 11, 2005 7:53 am
Location: Germany

by blackthunder

HI,

look at this cranks

http://www.gass-project.com/carbon_allo ... 10_big.jpg

looks very good and very light!!

Jörg

Bed4d SL
Posts: 164
Joined: Fri Dec 24, 2004 3:20 am
Location: Goderich

by Bed4d SL

I'd say of the ones mentioned by you and Sargon, the Storck Power Arms are the best, followed by the Stronglight. I've got an entirecrank test by TopVélo if you want it PM me.

User avatar
Mav54
Posts: 32
Joined: Sat Mar 27, 2004 5:58 pm

by Mav54

[quote="Sargon"]Hi Fester,

A few thoughts.

Thanks, I've been looking for that explanation!!

Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post