Record or DA?

Discuss light weight issues concerning road bikes & parts.
User avatar
Incomplete Pete
Posts: 97
Joined: Thu May 29, 2003 5:56 pm

by Incomplete Pete

Hm....good question!

www.racycles.com

This place often has good deals on complete bikes...but shipping would be expensive!

http://www.parker-international.co.uk/s ... ramset.htm

This place in the UK has some of the cheaper prices if you were to buy the group on it's own.

by Weenie


User avatar
Bruiser
Posts: 1386
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2002 1:59 am
Location: Sydney, Australia
Contact:

by Bruiser

Because the US$ has depreciated importing is now much cheaper for us.
Our $ is worth 15c more than when the retail prices were set.

Thanks for the links

Brian

doozer
Posts: 198
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2003 11:24 am
Location: fragglerock

by doozer

regarding the campag shimano debate you really have to focus upon the shifting. After all i expect most riders here run aftermarket BB's, chainsets, cassettes, brakes and cables. all that's really left are the shift/brake levers and the front and rear mechs.

Doozer :mrgreen:
Dance you cares away, worries for another day, dance your cares away, down at fragglerock.

andrew
Posts: 108
Joined: Wed Feb 18, 2004 10:19 pm

by andrew

DA10 is a very light shift.... there is feedback, but not as much as campy... it is precise, but very "light." very little effort is required to shift... maybe too little effort? the throw has been shortened and the levers are closer to bar now.

i find shifting campy levers from the drops almost impossible. but maybe i didnt setup my bars/shifters at the right angle.


Bruiser wrote:I've never used Campy and have been looking at buying DA. Is the 10speed DA a good shift (I've heard good things so far)?
I live in the drops, is the campy shift natural from the drops?

Brian

andrew
Posts: 108
Joined: Wed Feb 18, 2004 10:19 pm

by andrew

I prefer the ergonomics of the Campy hoods/levers. I love the thumb shift, don't have much trouble with it, I guess I'm used to it; but I do like the fact that you do have to go feel for it a bit. I don't like the feel of Shimano hoods, the angle and height.


what angle do you setup your bars/shifters so that you have no problem with the thumb button? do you think it is a matter of getting use to? i only have about 100 miles on my campy bike.

i also like the fact that there is lots of feedback when you shift.

the new DA10 hoods are strange... im not sure if like them or not.. they are very shinny near your hand (kind of like DA9 shifters from a few years ago), and then the rise quite a bit so that the top of the shifter is very high up....they didnt feel very good on a friends bike... maybe you have to setup the bars/shiftesr like Lance (shifters rotated far upwards)


Two details....I love the Campy quick release in the lever, not on the caliper, and more so I like the cleaner hidden routing of the cables up front.
But, you asked about ergonomics, which is exactly that: what fits one may not fit another....I think you said you work in a bike shop: so you certainly must have the opportunity to try both systems out: do it, see what you think.
Ergonomics equal, my instinct is if you buy Shimano you'll always think "should I have bought Campagnolo"; if you buy Campagnolo you'll just be happy.


Campy has the details down... I agree.

I have tried both out and I'm still undecided... Hopefully someone here can sway me in one position or the other... that's why i posted the question :)

User avatar
cadence90
Posts: 1694
Joined: Sun Dec 14, 2003 1:52 am

by cadence90

Incomplete Pete wrote:I use DA 10 speed and it's fantastic! I've used campy before but didn't like the leavers and the shifting was far too clunky and horrible. The new DA is awesome, the shifting is slick but firm....it's just a very well designed the system. The levers are ideal too, nice and ergonomic and their operation is vert smooth.

Campy is pretty, but personally I don't think it's very functional.


"....clunky and horrible."? :shock:
"....don't think it's very functional." :?: :shock:

Wow, what vintage Campagnolo was that???
The Record and the Chorus are the smoothest out there, IMHO.
"Gimondi è un eroe umano, che viene sconfitto ma che continua la sua corsa fino a tornare a vincere." - Enrico Ruggeri

User avatar
nzkiwiguy
Posts: 360
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2004 10:18 pm
Location: Colorado

by nzkiwiguy

I'm a D.A guy. Had no problems with lots of miles on the 9-speed. Have just started using some of the 10 speed components on a 9 speed set up on my TT bike.

Supposedly the reach on the new DA shifters is shorter, good if you run your hoods high.

While I like the look of the new stuff - there is something about Campy carbon that is sexy. If I ever got to build my dream bike a PINARELLO MONTELLO CRONO or Colnago Carbonissimo it would with a carbon campy drivetrain.

Joel
Posts: 751
Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Belgium

by Joel

I prefer Record:
Pro: Better durability of most parts
Lighter
It's just beautiful and the hoods are very ergonomic, the shiftingsystem is just the best
con: Maybe a higher price
Crancks: I don't know why people don't like square taper. The durability is far more better than with ISIS etc. and it's maybe 10g heavier. The Record crancks are also symetric. I don't know about the knew Shimano, but the DA 9s crancks were asymetric. I have also questions about the q factor of the new Shimano cranks. With my Record crancks I have about 3mm space between my feet and the BB bolts. With the outside bearings of the DA I think I should touch the BB bolts unless the q factor is higher.

520 Dan
Posts: 3308
Joined: Wed Oct 08, 2003 4:15 am
Location: tucson
Contact:

by 520 Dan

the isis vs. square taper durability thing is a good point, check out the link
http://www.campyonly.com/roadtests/2003/isis.html

User avatar
secularist
Posts: 32
Joined: Sun Jan 25, 2004 6:00 am
Location: MD/VA

by secularist

I've used both and tuned plenty while I was working in a shop. Once I got my Record gruppo, there was no turning back. I can appreciate what everyone says about Shimano, but it's just not for me anymore. I need a bit more flair and style to go with the precision of my bike parts. More carbon=more better!!! Some part of this whole 'bike worship' thing we're all into here is about parts that WOW us on an emotional level...that's more Campy to me. Shimano makes me go "oh...cool." But not like when I see any picture of any bike with Boras on it and then my heart starts to race!

I just don't think that there are very many people who, if given a coupon for a free gruppo of their choice would go with DA. I was like 16 when I got into road bikes and there was nothing cooler than the Ciocc with Super Record (and Ambrosio rims with Clement tubies...gotta love the old school) that was in some silly magazine I had. I didn't drool over DA when all I could afford was Shimano 600...Campy was IT!

There are differences in feel and I think that's a good thing...to each, his own. I like the larger platform on Campy hoods and the definite steps of the shifting. I think it feels more precise, actually.

Campy is a tad more finicky to set up, but once broken in a tad, I think it holds adjustments better than Shimano. And of course Campy is rebuildable...as opposed to replaceable.

That said I have a Suzuki motorcycle (and a Toyota truck...) not a Ducati or Aprilia. So I'm not insane about the Italian thing...

Cheers
I miss my IndyFab Crown Jewel...

User avatar
cadence90
Posts: 1694
Joined: Sun Dec 14, 2003 1:52 am

by cadence90

To Andrew's reach/angle questions: that's going to depend also on which bar you use, not just the shifters: some "ergo" bars are just "wrongo" ergonomically, for some people. It takes some adjustment.
I think shifting feedback is good, you develop a body memory.
The relative proportions of the elements (upshift/downshift/brake/hood/lever to bar) for me are better on the Campagnolo.
And secularist is right: there is an emotional aspect:
but this debate is goin' on forever so better just think about Shimano versus Campagnolo and sing:

"...Half of the people can be part right all of the time,
Some of the people can be all right part of the time.
I think Abraham Lincoln said that..."
- Bob Dylan, "TALKIN' WORLD WAR III BLUES" :)
"Gimondi è un eroe umano, che viene sconfitto ma che continua la sua corsa fino a tornare a vincere." - Enrico Ruggeri

bobalou
Posts: 1013
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 6:05 am

by bobalou

Shimano is easier to install and adjust. Campy works better when adjusted properly. Campy is lighter. A big thing though as far as quiet operation and durability has to do with maintenance. Keeping the drivetrain clean, lubed and adjusted. I use dry lube primarily, but mix 1/2 Finish-line teflon plus with White lighting. Drivetrain stays super clean and quiet. Changing the chain often will also keep the drivetrain quiet and the cassettes and rings will last longer also.

Personally, all things considered, I prefer campy, the clean look on the bars, the lightness, the operation .. but like the DA upshift, you get a little more leverage. Sometimes the rubber hood on the ergo get's a little twisted to the side from lots of up-shifting, that's annoying. Don't happen with DA. If I could find ergo-levers that had the DA upshift with the campy thumb downshift I'd probably buy it given it were the same weight. Hell.. I've spent too much money as it is, I hope nobody comes out with it. :?

User avatar
Cyco
Posts: 1903
Joined: Sat Nov 30, 2002 4:49 am

by Cyco

Having riden lots of both, I am currently running DA 9 and will soon move to DA 10.

The Campag hidden cables look nicer, but their (to me -and Big Jan) older "pointy top" levers wre more comfortable and looked better. But I still prefer the ergonomics if the Shimano levers (as one Shimano engineer described it - Shimano designs the component to fit the rider and then makes it work on a bike, Campagnolo designs bicycle components that a rider can use).

Campag gruppos are not as technically advanced as Shimano ones. Campag uses lots of black cloth, but Shimano's designers have come up with some brilliant designs (Cranks, chains, and the whole idea of STI levers)- that go together well, last brilliantly and are much cheaper to maintain.

I have to strongly disagree with the idea of being disapointed with DA long term, DA (IMHO) works better, lasts longer, copes with abuse better, is cheaper in the long term, and (whilst this may be different elsewhere in the world) in Australia Shimano parts are available at every shop whereas Campag is often order only.

p.s. Rouge and Super, The CSL is the most amazing thing the Bavarians have released in a while, looks heaps meaner than the standard M3, and the noise it make when the loud pedal is pressed in "M Track Mode" is amazing!

Edit: Postscript, and Shimano quote
Last edited by Cyco on Fri Feb 20, 2004 10:17 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Success is how far you you bounce back up after being knocked down

User avatar
asphaltdude
Posts: 1234
Joined: Tue Aug 12, 2003 8:39 pm
Location: Holland
Contact:

by asphaltdude

I like STI more than Ergopower, but that's a personal thing.
Whow! That's a pretty damn nice garage door!

by Weenie


mises
Posts: 1769
Joined: Tue Dec 23, 2003 9:28 pm
Location: Unknown parameter

by mises

DA and Campy are like an American Luxury car vs. an Italian sports car respectively. DA wants to isolate you from everything and Campy has the stiff shocks and stab clutch. I like the sports car myself, but it's a subjective choice.

I have never been that impressed with DA durability though it's better than it used to be. I always like the old Mavic SSC group from the late 80's the best. That stuff lasted forever. Second would be campy, not as long lasting but you can replace any little part you have to. I do think the BB is anachronistic at this point, I was disappointed they didn't go to ISIS for 04. It's not that hard to pop out sealed bearings once in a while in exchange for more stiffness.

Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post