domane seat post crack... warranty-able?
Moderator: robbosmans
-
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 3:10 pm
I had the same problem with my Madone seat mast and they told me to pound sand (always torque wrenched) . Glad it worked out better for you.
Visit starbike.com Online Retailer for HighEnd cycling components
Great Prices ✓ Broad Selection ✓ Worldwide Delivery ✓
www.starbike.com
Fisherfreerider wrote:The max torque on our seat masts is 7nM and the Bontrager preset torque wrench is 5nM so he is not over-torquing anything.
The correct torque is the minimum needed to fix the seat mast securely without going over the MAX torque spec for the BOLT. So if 4Nm is sufficient to hold the seat mast, then why crank it to 5Nm. The OP stated that he always used the 5 Nm preset key, yet the seatmast still damaged the seat tube. Assuming he did everything correctly are you saying he should confidently crank it to 5 Nm again?
EM3
______________
Here another person with a cracked Trek Set Post (2013 Madone 5.2). The crack looks exactly the same as in a picture shown in an earlier post. Right now Trek is evaluating the claim my bike shop sent (10 days ago already!).
I'm fearing Trek won't replace the frame as all signs look like the seat post was over torqued. Having a torque wrench I always feared torquing it to the max 7Nm (that Trek /Bontrager say is safe to apply) because it is really, really tight, so I never torqued all the way to 7Nm, but still the seat post cracked, apparently during one of my rides.
Anyway, I checked out some companies that can fix carbon and if Trek doesn't come forward, I'll most likely get it fixed for about $300.
As someone mentioned "we" should just ask our dealer and leave it up to Trek .. I'm glad others shared their story and turns out more people have the exact same problem. To me that looks like a manufacturing issue Trek might want to look into, because it's not right a frame can be damaged that bad by a seat post!
I'm fearing Trek won't replace the frame as all signs look like the seat post was over torqued. Having a torque wrench I always feared torquing it to the max 7Nm (that Trek /Bontrager say is safe to apply) because it is really, really tight, so I never torqued all the way to 7Nm, but still the seat post cracked, apparently during one of my rides.
Anyway, I checked out some companies that can fix carbon and if Trek doesn't come forward, I'll most likely get it fixed for about $300.
As someone mentioned "we" should just ask our dealer and leave it up to Trek .. I'm glad others shared their story and turns out more people have the exact same problem. To me that looks like a manufacturing issue Trek might want to look into, because it's not right a frame can be damaged that bad by a seat post!